iHeartDogs is reader-supported. When you purchase by way of hyperlinks on our web site, we could earn an affiliate fee at no additional price to you.
Many canine dad and mom are making the change to recent pet food as a result of it’s usually more healthy and extra customizable than kibble. Yet, in case your canine has been consuming dry meals their complete life, it may be a drastic change. So, you’ll have to take plenty of points into consideration earlier than selecting the very best recent pet food model to your furry good friend.
Nom Nom and The Farmer’s Dog are two of the most well-liked recent pet food manufacturers. So, let’s check out how they examine in a number of areas that will help you resolve if both is an efficient match to your canine.
What is Fresh Dog Food?
Fresh pet food is often made with recent, pure substances which might be cooked at a decrease temperature to protect their vitamins. When you have a look at the pet food, you’ll see full chunks of meat and greens, so that you’ll know precisely what’s going into your canine’s tummy. Most recent pet food manufacturers provide customizable plans to cater to your canine’s wants.
However, recent substances imply the meals has a shorter shelf life. So, the meals will have to be refrigerated or frozen to maintain it recent. To be certain that your canine’s recent meals by no means goes dangerous, the manufacturers will ship the meals on a daily schedule. The formulation are sometimes made particularly to your canine earlier than being despatched to your door.
Many pet dad and mom haven’t tried recent meals but as a result of it’s pricier than kibble. Yet, the value is value it when you take into account the standard of substances and customization supplied. Plus, many canines favor the flavour of recent meals over dry meals. If it’s inside your finances, it’s value a attempt.
Overview of the Fresh Dog Food Brands
If you’re contemplating shopping for recent pet food to your pup, Nom Nom and Farmer’s Dog are two manufacturers you’ll possible come throughout. Here are the points we’ll examine:
- Ingredients
- Customization
- Convenience
- Variety
- Price
- Storage
- Safety
- Customer Service
Nom Nom
Facebook
Nom Nom is a customizable recent pet food model. After filling out a questionnaire about your canine, they may formulate a customized meal plan to your canine. The meals are shipped chilly and recent to your door, and so they’re in serving-size packages. The meals is gently cooked to protect vitamins, and it’s freed from filler substances.
The Farmer’s Dog
Facebook
The Farmer’s Dog is the same firm. They additionally function by asking you to fill out a collection of questions to allow them to create a customized meal to your canine. The meals ships to your door in frozen, ready-to-serve packages on a schedule. Like Nom Nom, all of the recipes are cooked at a low temperature to keep up a excessive dietary worth.
Nom Nom vs Farmer’s Dog
Now that you realize a bit about every model, let’s dive into the small print of their qualities. For every class, we’ll record a winner, despite the fact that they’re shut calls. One model isn’t total higher than the opposite, so it’s as much as you to resolve which classes matter most to your canine.
Ingredients
Facebook
Both manufacturers use recent, human-grade substances. The ingredient lists offers you a transparent understanding of what you’re giving your canine. While the ingredient high quality of each manufacturers is comparable, they use distinctive formulation.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s recipes are created in made-to-order batches. The substances are recent and slow-cooked to protect vitamins. Real meat is at all times listed as the primary ingredient of their recipes, adopted by substances like potatoes, eggs, and brown rice, relying on the recipe.
About 72% to 77% of the meals is moisture, so round 7% to 10% is protein. Each method makes use of one predominant protein paired with a collection of greens like candy potatoes, carrots, and spinach. The full ingredient record and assured evaluation are listed on Nom Nom’s web site, so you’ll have some thought of what to anticipate earlier than filling out your canine’s particulars.
Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog additionally slow-cooks made-to-order recipes from recent substances. Like Nom Nom, meat can also be the primary ingredient listed, adopted by greens like carrots, inexperienced beans, and broccoli. They additionally deal with fiber-rich substances like chickpeas, lentils, and candy potatoes.
This model doesn’t record recipe particulars on its web site, equivalent to potential ingredient lists and assured evaluation. However, different sources state that the recipes have between 73% and 77% moisture and 9% to 11% protein. Their ingredient lists are additionally shorter than Nom Nom’s which could possibly be good for canines with allergic reactions.
Winner: Farmer’s Dog
It’s a really shut name, however Farmer’s Dog wins as a result of it’s higher for delicate canines. Not solely does it have fewer substances, nevertheless it avoids greens that don’t add as a lot dietary worth and will trigger allergic reactions, equivalent to russet potatoes and peas. However, Nom Nom stands out as a result of it has all its dietary info simply accessible on the web site whereas Farmer’s Dog doesn’t.
Customization
Facebook
Both manufacturers provide personalised meals for canines, however their strategies of gathering info are barely totally different. Both of them require you to fill out a questionnaire earlier than they’ll suggest the meals.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom asks plenty of common questions on your canine, equivalent to their breed, intercourse, age, weight, and physique situation. They additionally ask if canines have particular well being circumstances, equivalent to joint considerations, digestive issues, and allergic reactions. If your canine’s situation isn’t listed, they counsel you contact them. You can discuss with their canine nutritionist to resolve which method is finest to your canine’s wants.
Even although they ask about well being circumstances, they don’t have any formulation which might be particularly designed to assist these areas. For instance, when you mark that your canine has allergic reactions, they’ll counsel the pork recipe since its substances are the least prone to trigger allergic reactions somewhat than discovering out what particular allergic reactions your canine has.
Farmer’s Dog
Farmer’s Dog asks for lots of the identical info, plus a number of additional issues. They need to know your canine’s breed, intercourse, weight, age, physique form, exercise degree, present meals, and whether or not they’re fastened or not. The additional components can have an effect on calorie rely. They additionally ask about your pup’s present well being circumstances.
Like Nom Nom, not one of the meals are particularly made to assist with sure well being circumstances, however the model will suggest which method is finest based mostly on the way you reply the questions. Right off the bat, in addition they ask you a number of private questions earlier than moving into your canine’s particulars.
Winner: Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog questionnaire is extra detailed than Nom Nom, making the meals just a little extra personalised. However, meaning it should additionally take longer to get your canine’s meal plan arrange.
Convenience
Facebook
Convenience is necessary to each these manufacturers as a result of they package deal the meals, hold it chilly, and ship it to your door so that you don’t have to hold meals residence from the shop.
Nom Nom
When Nom Nom’s meals arrives at your door, it’s already portioned into serving sizes. So, all you need to do is open a package deal for every meal with out doing any measuring. The packages are saved in a field with dry ice to maintain the meals chilly till you obtain it. The packaging is handy and reveals you precisely what number of energy your canine is getting, nevertheless it means you could have extra packaging to recycle consequently.
The first parts you obtain from Nom Nom will probably be transition meals. So, they’re smaller parts that you would be able to combine together with your canine’s outdated meals for every week to keep away from digestive issues. If your canine is already consuming recent meals, you’ll be able to select to skip the transition meals. Unused meals must be saved within the freezer, nevertheless it must be moved to the fridge 24 hours upfront to thaw.
Farmer’s Dog
This model’s meals can also be packaged with dry ice to maintain it chilly till you obtain it. Each package deal has the identical quantity of meals, so you will have to portion out the meals based mostly on the model’s directions. Small canines can get about eight meals out of 1 pack, whereas giant canines could solely get one or two. The firm packages the meals like this to cut back plastic utilization.
The packs usually are not resealable as soon as open, however you’ll be able to fold up unused parts and retailer them within the fridge of their biodegradable storage container. Any unopened packages may be frozen, however you’ll want to recollect to thaw them 24 hours earlier than your canine’s meal.
Winner: Nom Nom
Nom Nom is by far the higher possibility for comfort as a result of it has pre-portioned packages, so that you gained’t have to fret about measuring out your canine’s meals and making a large number.
Variety
Facebook
Not all canines have the identical favourite flavors, and a few canines have allergic reactions and sensitivities. So, having a wide range of product choices is a good way to make sure that each pup will get what they want.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom presents 4 predominant recipes, every with a special protein: Beef Mash, Chicken Cuisine, Pork Potluck, and Turkey Fare. You can select between half and full meals parts relying in your canine’s wants. The firm additionally presents a number of dietary supplements to present canines a well being enhance.
Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog makes use of the identical 4 meat proteins of their meals: pork, rooster, turkey, and beef. You can order full meals or select a topper plan when you’d somewhat combine it with dry meals. Farmer’s Dog doesn’t provide any further treats or dietary supplements.
Winner: Nom Nom
Even although the 2 manufacturers have related meal choices, Nom Nom goes a bit above and past by additionally providing dietary supplements.
Price
Facebook
Both manufacturers are priced equally, however the price of meals will differ based mostly in your canine’s weight and dietary wants. For reference, dry pet food usually prices $1 to $2 per day, however costs differ based mostly on the model.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom meals begin at $2 per day. Half meals that you would be able to combine together with your canine’s dry meals will probably be cheaper than full meals. For full meals, small canines are between $2 and $5 per day, medium canines are $5 to $7 per day, and enormous canines are $7 to $14 per day.
Shipping is free, and you may get your a reimbursement inside 30 days of receiving the primary field when you’re not happy.
Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog has related costs. Their meals additionally begin at $2 per day. Small canines will price $2 to $5 per day, medium canines will price $6 to $8 per day, and enormous canines will price $8 to $11 per day.
Shipping is free, and when you’re not happy with the meals, you may get a full refund when you donate the meals to a shelter or rescue.
Winner: Farmer’s Dog
There isn’t an enormous distinction in pricing for these two manufacturers, however Farmer’s Dog has a greater deal for giant canines, despite the fact that their meals for medium canines are barely extra. Nom Nom’s meals for giant canines usually surpass $10 per day, whereas The Farmer’s Dog not often sells meals that price that a lot.
The Farmer’s Dog additionally has a greater coverage for refunds. Customers at all times have a chance to get a refund if not happy, and the model encourages shelter donations too.
Storage
Facebook
Dog meals can take up plenty of house, however recent meals particularly must go within the fridge or freezer. So, is it simple to retailer these manufacturers?
Nom Nom
When you obtain the meals, you’ll be able to put the primary two meals within the fridge and the remainder within the freezer. The meals wants 24 hours to thaw, so while you serve a meal to your canine, you’ll be able to put one other meal within the fridge to arrange for the following day. You can stand up to a weekly supply for Nom Nom, so the meals gained’t take up an excessive amount of house at a time.
Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog sends bigger packages, so they might take up more room in your fridge or freezer. However, like Nom Nom, you’ll be able to select how usually you’d prefer to obtain meals. One week is essentially the most frequent supply possibility.
Winner: Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s luggage are smaller, making them simpler to retailer. Since every package deal can also be one serving, you by no means have to fret about storing already-opened luggage.
Safety
Facebook
Safety must be a precedence for all pet food manufacturers. Luckily, neither model has had any recollects. Both manufacturers are additionally protected for the surroundings as a result of they use recyclable, compostable, and biodegradable packaging.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom makes use of substances sourced within the United States, and so they deal with sustainable sourcing every time potential. The meals meets USDA and AAFCO requirements, nevertheless it’s not cooked in USDA-certified kitchens. Nom Nom works with veterinary nutritionists to formulate the most secure meals for canines.
Farmer’s Dog
The Farmer’s Dog solely sources meals from suppliers authorised by the USDA, and their meals exceeds AAFCO requirements. The substances are then cooked in USDA-certified kitchens. They have the identical requirements as human meals manufacturing. Farmer’s Dog additionally works with veterinary nutritionists when formulating recipes.
Winner: Farmer’s Dog
Both firms have related security requirements, however Farmer’s Dog gained by only a hair as a result of they prepare dinner their meals in USDA-certified kitchens.
Customer Service
Facebook
Finally, customer support is a vital facet that’s usually forgotten. You’ll desire a model that’s simple to get in contact with if in case you have any questions.
Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s communication is very rated. According to prospects, the corporate makes it simple to alter, pause, or cancel your order. If something is incorrect together with your order, they’re fast to reply and repair it. When you place an order, they ship an e mail so you’ll be able to observe the place it’s.
When it involves fundamental questions, you may not even have to contact the corporate. Nom Nom’s web site has plenty of particulars about its merchandise and course of, so you’ll be able to study lots about them with no need to speak to anybody.
Farmer’s Dog
Farmer’s Dog’s customer support has extra combined critiques than Nom Nom, however most are constructive. Customers have stated that they’re fast to reply to points, and so they go above and past to make issues proper. Some critiques even said that they ship flowers when pets cross away.
They even have plenty of generally requested questions on their web site, however they lack particulars about their meals formulation, so you would need to name to ask about that.
Winner: Nom Nom
Nom Nom’s customer support has extra reward from prospects than The Farmer’s Dog, and so they have extra info on their web site. Yet, each firms appear to have nice communication.
Choosing the Best Fresh Dog Food
Overall, each Nom Nom and The Farmer’s Dog are a number of the finest recent pet food firms. To resolve which one is healthier to your canine, you’ll want to take a look at all of the points talked about above. The Farmer’s Dog gained a number of classes whereas Nom Nom gained others, so that you’ll want to consider which areas matter most to you. No matter which one you select, your canine will probably be having fun with flavorful human-grade meals.
